Sunday, November 29, 2009

My Thoughts on Max Hall

Another classic Holy War (sloppy offenses and sloppier officiating notwithstanding), and unfortunately it will probably be most remembered because of Max Hall’s postgame comments (Greg Wrubell always says it best)—not because of the physical defense or the clutch field goals on both sides, or even Andrew George hitting pay-dirt and getting his moment in the spotlight.

Let me start by saying I have never completely understood the criticism of Max Hall from the BYU side. Have we lost big games to TCU and Utah because of his turnovers? Yes, in part. But would we have won 31 games over the last three years without him? I doubt it. You live and die with your quarterback. So why do some BYU fans throw him under the bus if the offensive line can’t give him protection or the receivers are covered well down field? I believe that a majority of Max’s frustration rests not with Utah, but with certain fans in Provo. You know, the same types who egged defensive coordinator Jaime Hill’s house after the Florida State game, or those who made the BYU players look forward to playing AWAY from Lavell Edwards Stadium this year. For illustration, I go back to a comment I heard in the stands last year: “Dude, Pitta can’t catch anything.” Oh, you mean Dennis Pitta? National Finalist for the Mackey Award? Now BYU’s career leader in receptions? Just checking. The important point here is that there are just a few, very vocal idiots that ruin it for the rest of us. I feel bad for Max Hall that he doesn’t seem to recognize that same fact on the Utah side.

I don’t know what happened to Max’s family last year at Rice-Eccles, but I’m sure if some Ute fans made nasty comments about or poured beer on my family, I might be holding a personal grudge too. But who could possibly condone what he said after the game yesterday, expressing collective hatred toward the Utah team, its fans, and the institution? Again, I can see where he’s coming from—I’ve said and done my fair share of stupid stuff just playing intramurals, so I can’t imagine the pressure and scrutiny he’s faced in the last year as the BYU quarterback. I wish he hadn’t taken it so far, because I know how he’s going to feel when he understands the full impact of his words. Even if getting all that off his chest made him feel better in the moment, he will be haunted and reminded about it for the rest of his life. In the end, I just don’t think it was worth it.

I hope that he will be remembered instead as the quarterback who led us to three consecutive bowls, three 10+ win seasons, a conference championship in 2007, and one big win over Oklahoma. You can’t deny that he has been one fiery, competitive leader—yes, sometimes too much so for his own good. And I think most Cougar fans will only really recognize what Max Hall meant to the offense when he’s gone next year. Maybe the separation will be good for all parties—Max can get some fresh air in his native Arizona, BYU fans can begin the Jake Heaps hype, and Utah can cool their jets and figure out a viable offensive plan for next year’s game. Whatever transpires in the next three weeks, let us all remember: we are the 2nd and 3rd place teams in the conference, and you get to Vegas and San Diego by the same I-15, due south. Be kind on the roads and let us be grateful for our second-class bowl games and the behemoth that is TCU.

Saturday, September 19, 2009

BlogSport II

As I recall, last year I wrote my thoughts after every game until BYU lost to TCU and ended the season in underwhelming fashion. My enthusiasm waned as I watched the defense struggle to contain even the likes of UNLV, to say nothing of the Utah and Arizona games. Well, a new season finds the Cougars at (a frankly surprising) 2-0, and after seeing Bradford get Clawson'd and Tulane get steamrolled, my hopes are again at a dangerous high.

1. The Oklahoma game was probably the first game since the 2005 season that I didn't fully expect BYU to win. In my mind, 2006's team was meant for bigger and better things, but the early and close losses at Boston College and Arizona killed any hype early—the 2007 team had a similar fate, but 11-2 is nothing to snuff at. If 2008's fast start meant nothing but a late season letdown, I believe the Cougars of 2009 are, for lack of a better term, "for real." I like the offensive balance, and I think the execution will only improve as the year goes on. And the defense that seemed to degenerate into obscurity last season has remarkably renewed toughness and confidence.

2. That brings us to today’s game in Provo against Florida State. I really wish I could be there to help rock Lavell Edwards Stadium and drown out the Seminole tomahawk chants. BYU just has to avoid giving up the big plays, i.e. kickoff returns, interception returns, etc. and I think they will be fine. Home field advantage is a big deal when you are 18-0 in Provo since 2006, and altitude always eventually gets to those supposedly more athletic squads (just ask UCLA, I'll bet they don't schedule another game in Utah for 20 years). Please protect the new sod!

3. I started grad school at the University of Denver this week, and so far I am very impressed with the quality of campus resources, my professors, and fellow students. Amy will tell you I was pretty stressed out after my first day, but I have started to settle in. This semester I am T.A.-ing for a section of beginning managerial accounting and taking classes in IT (focused mostly on Access and Visio), Family Business, and Essence of Enterprise. That course is just as vague as an "essence of" anything class would be, but we do a lot of good foundational reading on values-based leadership, sustainable development, and ethics in the business setting, which I have to say, unfortunately, intellectually trumps anything I encountered at BYU on the subject (somehow, in a college education replete with gospel insights, ethics were treated as a given, and it was probably my worst-taught class at BYU). Which brings me to my final thought:

4. Last night we watched Quiz Show, the great Robert Redford-directed film about the real-life frauds perpetuated by the producers of an old TV game show. The screenplay is pretty sharp, and I feel it is a thought-provoking commentary on trust and the media, but more so the effects of deception on individuals. It was easy to make some connections with some of the material I’ve been reading for my class. I am taking it completely out of context, but I really identified with this quote by Charles Van Doren, played by Ralph Fiennes:

"It may sound trite to you, but I have found myself again after a number of years. I've been acting a role, maybe all my life, of thinking I've done more, accomplished more, produced more than I have. I've had all the breaks. I have stood on the shoulders of life and I have never got down into the dirt to build, to erect a foundation of my own. I have flown too high on borrowed wings. Everything came too easy. That is why I am here today."

Thursday, September 3, 2009

Dreaming of Williamsport



I spent the last couple weeks of August following the Little League World Series televised on ESPN from Williamsport, PA. I usually try to catch a game or two on TV every year, but I was more invested this time in following the team from Chula Vista, CA and their explosive offense. It was gratifying to see them win the World Championship and avenge all the other California teams that have lost to Chinese-Taipei in years past.

When I was a 12-year-old All-Star for Tustin National Little League, I saw some limited action playing left field, despite what I felt was a breakout year for me at first base for the Cardinals. I think we lost our first two games and were eliminated immediately from regionals. I was never a great hitter, at times maybe a prolific bunter, but never a power swinger with my skinny frame. I had plenty of singles, but rarely any doubles or triples, and NEVER any home runs. But I have many fond memories of those times, starting in AA with the Cubs, AAA with the Cardinals, Majors with the Astros and the Cardinals again, then finally the Orioles and the Expos after the league converted to the PONY format. From age 8 to 14, I played baseball and loved it, before giving it up for volleyball, a sport my body was more suited to play.

Recently I have been playing softball with McGladrey (the company I interned with this summer) in an intramural league here in Denver. Yesterday's game started out unspectacularly, as we found ourselves down early, 7-1. I came up to bat in the 3rd with the bases loaded and an opportunity to help engineer a comeback after flying out to center in my first at-bat. I grounded out to first, bringing in a run, and by the end of the inning we were sitting at 7-5. I took a hard liner off the side of the ankle in the top of the 4th, but fortunately the ball deflected to the second baseman and we still got the force out. Our defense held and I came up to bat again with the same score. With a runner on first, I ripped the ball to right-center, another potentially easy catch for the center fielder. He charged to snag the ball, but he misjudged it badly and it sailed six feet over his head. As I rounded second, I saw he was just getting the ball, and agreed with my team's judgment to put on the wheels and head home. Two-run home run, tie game. We later scored the go-ahead run to make it 8-7 going into the 6th. They scored a run to tie it up again in the top of inning. We had a double to start the bottom of the 6th, a pop-out, then a ground ball to third that caught the lead-runner coming from second. Runner at first, two outs, and the game ends in a tie barring the go-ahead run. My turn to bat again, I took the first pitch high for a ball. I cocked my bat on the next pitch and sent a liner to right-center, no chance of being caught on the fly this time. The runner from first approached third and with a moment's hesitation, judged the fielder's arm and bolted for home plate. I reached second base and pumped my fist, a game-winning double. 2 for 3 on the day with 4 RBIs and a run scored, and a tender ankle as a reminder of a great day of competitive softball. Someday I'll get to Williamsport, but only as a spectator.