Another classic Holy War (sloppy offenses and sloppier officiating notwithstanding), and unfortunately it will probably be most remembered because of Max Hall’s postgame comments (Greg Wrubell always says it best)—not because of the physical defense or the clutch field goals on both sides, or even Andrew George hitting pay-dirt and getting his moment in the spotlight.
Let me start by saying I have never completely understood the criticism of Max Hall from the BYU side. Have we lost big games to TCU and Utah because of his turnovers? Yes, in part. But would we have won 31 games over the last three years without him? I doubt it. You live and die with your quarterback. So why do some BYU fans throw him under the bus if the offensive line can’t give him protection or the receivers are covered well down field? I believe that a majority of Max’s frustration rests not with Utah, but with certain fans in Provo. You know, the same types who egged defensive coordinator Jaime Hill’s house after the Florida State game, or those who made the BYU players look forward to playing AWAY from Lavell Edwards Stadium this year. For illustration, I go back to a comment I heard in the stands last year: “Dude, Pitta can’t catch anything.” Oh, you mean Dennis Pitta? National Finalist for the Mackey Award? Now BYU’s career leader in receptions? Just checking. The important point here is that there are just a few, very vocal idiots that ruin it for the rest of us. I feel bad for Max Hall that he doesn’t seem to recognize that same fact on the Utah side.
I don’t know what happened to Max’s family last year at Rice-Eccles, but I’m sure if some Ute fans made nasty comments about or poured beer on my family, I might be holding a personal grudge too. But who could possibly condone what he said after the game yesterday, expressing collective hatred toward the Utah team, its fans, and the institution? Again, I can see where he’s coming from—I’ve said and done my fair share of stupid stuff just playing intramurals, so I can’t imagine the pressure and scrutiny he’s faced in the last year as the BYU quarterback. I wish he hadn’t taken it so far, because I know how he’s going to feel when he understands the full impact of his words. Even if getting all that off his chest made him feel better in the moment, he will be haunted and reminded about it for the rest of his life. In the end, I just don’t think it was worth it.
I hope that he will be remembered instead as the quarterback who led us to three consecutive bowls, three 10+ win seasons, a conference championship in 2007, and one big win over Oklahoma. You can’t deny that he has been one fiery, competitive leader—yes, sometimes too much so for his own good. And I think most Cougar fans will only really recognize what Max Hall meant to the offense when he’s gone next year. Maybe the separation will be good for all parties—Max can get some fresh air in his native Arizona, BYU fans can begin the Jake Heaps hype, and Utah can cool their jets and figure out a viable offensive plan for next year’s game. Whatever transpires in the next three weeks, let us all remember: we are the 2nd and 3rd place teams in the conference, and you get to Vegas and San Diego by the same I-15, due south. Be kind on the roads and let us be grateful for our second-class bowl games and the behemoth that is TCU.
Ashes & Ashes
1 week ago









